Who will win? IE8 vs Firefox 3
Posted by Patrick on 12 Mar 2008
As a disclaimer, this discussion will probably not be technical enough to satisfy the extremely passionate readers who have an opinion on one side or another. Further, the release cycles aren’t exactly in sync - as of this writing, IE8 has a developer-focused beta 1 available, while Mozilla is nearer release with Firefox 3 now in beta 4.
I’ve had IE8’s beta1 for around a week now. What really turns me on to IE8 is that the development team at MS is really trying to produce a next-gen browser capable of supporting standards for things like CSS 2.1 and HTML5. MS touts IE8 as a release aimed at creating and promoting interoperability - of course we have learned that we cannot place much trust in MS press releases about how good their products are going to be or even which features they will ultimately contain. In this case, however, I believe MS has some must-deliver goods on the table and the ultimate fate of IE’s viability hangs in the balance with this release.
Despite being the de facto browser for millions of PC users that know no better, it’s the developers who are writing these new, rich Internet multimedia technologies that are going to swing the pendulum one way or the other with IE8. If Joe User gets random crashes and badly rendered stuff in IE8, but gold-plated mastery in Firefox, then Joe is probably going to convert. The same is true for the converse - where people find Firefox to suck they will usually go with IE (I mean Windows users).
One interesting addition in IE8 that I want to see is the WebSlices feature. In my beta1 I’ve gotten it to work once but it was on static text in a page that holds little value. The point of webslices are to serve as mini-feeds that web services can implement/call and provide info back to the user without requiring the user to be in that webspace to do it. I love this function; I want to see it work first, though, before I start throwing myself at it.
But what about Firefox 3? First of all, unlike IE8, the Firefox project has their product requirements document publicly available on the Mozilla wiki. Some of the interesting features I pulled from the requirements document myself:
- Integrate with Vista Parental Controls
- Revised download manager
- Support for Linux ATK (accessibility)
- Several security improvements
I guess what I mean to say is that, it’s not a rewrite-style release like IE8, so the list of features isn’t going to include a bunch of grandiose “make the Internet cooler” type requirements. The honest truth is that IE8 is trying to catch up with and arguably surpass the capabilities of Firefox. While Firefox does have CSS issues from time to time - especially on sites that were written specifically for IE5.5 or IE6 - its version 2 evolved from feedback about what people wanted in IE but were less likely to “get”.
Ultimately, one of these browsers will prevail. For completely unrelated reasons, I’m going to say that Firefox is the real winner regardless of IE8’s potential successes. Corporate America is slowly moving its desktop users away from MS platforms and onto either Macs or Linux distributions (semantics at this level). I personally would like nothing more than to convert my laptop from Windows XP SP2 to something like K/Ubuntu or Fedora. In the Linux space, Firefox pretty much reigns though the flavors of browsing technology begin to vary vastly into personal preference when dealing with higher computer literacy percentages; the point there is that there’s no home for IE on Linux, and little welcome for it on Mac.
Posted in News Items, advice, opinion, technology | No Comments »










